Cody Rhodes has cemented himself as one of WWE’s most compelling figures in recent memory, undertaking a red-hot babyface run that has captivated audiences and defied conventional wrestling wisdom. Returning to WWE in 2022 after six years away, Cody reentered the promotion as a polished, mature performer with a renewed sense of purpose. What makes his journey remarkable is how he has redefined the archetype of a babyface in an era where fans often gravitate toward antiheroes and morally ambiguous characters.
A Triumphant Return
When Cody made his triumphant return at WrestleMania 38, facing Seth Rollins, he immediately struck a chord with fans. The American Nightmare persona—a blend of legacy, grit, and personal ambition—resonated with audiences. Unlike the polarizing “Superman” babyface characters of the past, Cody’s story felt authentic. His mission was clear: to claim the WWE Championship, a title his father, the legendary Dusty Rhodes, never won. This emotional undercurrent elevated Cody’s motives beyond mere competition, making his quest deeply relatable.
Defying Modern WWE Dynamics
One of the most surprising aspects of Cody’s babyface run is its sustained momentum. WWE fans are notoriously fickle when it comes to traditional “good guys.” Many babyfaces are met with diminishing reactions over time, often perceived as pandering or lacking depth. Cody has avoided these pitfalls through a combination of stellar storytelling, incredible in-ring performances, and an undeniable connection with the audience.
Part of Cody’s success lies in his ability to walk a fine line between humility and confidence. He exudes a genuine love for the wrestling business while projecting star power and self-assuredness. Fans respect his dedication to his craft, his polished promos, and his vulnerability. Cody isn’t afraid to show emotion, whether it’s tearing up while discussing his father or collapsing in exhaustion after a grueling match.
The Setback That Fueled the Fire
Cody’s babyface run faced a significant hurdle in 2022 when he suffered a torn pectoral muscle. Despite the injury, he delivered a gutsy performance against Seth Rollins in a Hell in a Cell match, fighting through visible pain with a grotesquely bruised chest. That match became an instant classic and solidified Cody’s reputation as a resilient, fearless competitor. The injury could have derailed his momentum, but instead, it added to his lore. His eventual return at the 2023 Royal Rumble was met with thunderous applause, proving fans had not forgotten his sacrifice.
The WrestleMania Near-Miss
Cody’s journey reached a critical moment at WrestleMania 39, where he faced Roman Reigns for the Undisputed WWE Universal Championship. While many expected Cody to dethrone Reigns and complete his story, the unexpected loss only deepened fan investment. The defeat was a rare instance where a loss enhanced a babyface’s aura. Cody’s perseverance in the face of adversity mirrored his real-life journey and left fans clamoring for his eventual triumph.
Why Cody’s Run Matters
Cody Rhodes’ babyface run is more than just a career milestone; it’s a testament to the power of storytelling and character work in wrestling. At a time when many fans cheer for villains or root for chaos, Cody has shown that a well-crafted babyface can still thrive. His ability to evoke genuine emotion, combined with his tireless work ethic, makes him one of the most compelling figures in WWE today.
As Cody continues his pursuit of championship gold, his story serves as a reminder that sometimes the most traditional narratives—those of heart, perseverance, and legacy—can shine brightest.
