Four Realistic Options the New York Jets Have to Replace Aaron Rodgers
The New York Jets faced a significant setback when Aaron Rodgers, their marquee offseason acquisition, suffered a season-ending Achilles injury early in the 2023 NFL season. Rodgers was expected to elevate the Jets to legitimate Super Bowl contenders, but his absence leaves a gaping hole at quarterback. The team must now explore viable options to salvage their season and maintain playoff aspirations. Here are four realistic paths the Jets could take to replace Rodgers:
1. Stick with Zach Wilson
The most straightforward option for the Jets is to double down on Zach Wilson, their 2021 second-overall draft pick. Wilson, while inconsistent during his first two NFL seasons, offers familiarity with the team’s system and personnel. Despite a rocky start to his career, he showed glimpses of improvement under Rodgers’ mentorship during training camp and preseason.
Wilson’s ability to extend plays with his athleticism and arm strength gives him potential upside. If head coach Robert Saleh and offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett can craft a conservative, run-first offense that minimizes Wilson’s exposure to high-risk throws, the Jets might remain competitive. However, for this option to work, Wilson must prove that he can handle the pressure and avoid turnovers, which have been a major issue in the past.
2. Trade for a Veteran Quarterback
The Jets could pursue a trade for an experienced quarterback. Several veteran options are available, depending on the team’s willingness to part with draft capital. Some potential targets include:
- Ryan Tannehill (Tennessee Titans): Tannehill is an experienced quarterback with playoff success who could provide stability. The Titans may be open to moving him, especially if they plan to transition to younger talent like Malik Willis or Will Levis.
- Jacoby Brissett (Washington Commanders): Brissett is a capable game manager and a proven leader. While he’s currently backing up Sam Howell, the Commanders might part with him for the right price.
- Jameis Winston (New Orleans Saints): Known for his big arm and risk-taking style, Winston could add a spark to the Jets’ offense. However, his penchant for turnovers might be a concern for the team’s defense-first philosophy.
While a trade would provide an immediate upgrade, it could also cost the Jets valuable draft picks and strain their salary cap.
3. Sign a Free Agent
Exploring the free-agent market is another option for the Jets, though the pool of available quarterbacks is limited. Some notable names include:
- Carson Wentz: The former Pro Bowl quarterback has experience as a starter but has struggled with consistency and turnovers in recent years. Still, his physical tools make him an intriguing option.
- Matt Ryan: The former MVP and longtime Atlanta Falcons quarterback is currently a free agent. Although Ryan’s mobility is limited at this stage of his career, his experience and leadership could be assets.
- Nick Foles: A Super Bowl-winning quarterback with a knack for stepping up in high-pressure situations, Foles could be a steadying presence for the Jets.
Signing a free agent would allow the Jets to avoid giving up draft capital, but the limited talent in the market makes this a less appealing option.
4. Explore a Bold Move for a Star
If the Jets are determined to make a splash, they could pursue a blockbuster trade for a star quarterback. While this is the least likely option, some intriguing possibilities exist:
- Kirk Cousins (Minnesota Vikings): Cousins is in the final year of his contract and could be available if the Vikings fall out of playoff contention. His consistent production and ability to thrive in play-action make him an attractive option.
- Kyler Murray (Arizona Cardinals): The Cardinals might consider moving Murray as they rebuild their roster. While acquiring him would be costly, Murray’s dual-threat abilities could transform the Jets’ offense.
These moves would be expensive, requiring significant draft capital and potentially restructuring contracts to fit under the salary cap. However, they would provide the Jets with a high-caliber quarterback who could immediately elevate the team.
Conclusion
Replacing Aaron Rodgers is no easy task, but the Jets have multiple paths forward. Whether they stick with Zach Wilson, trade for a veteran, sign a free agent, or make a bold move for a star, each option comes with its own set of risks and rewards. The team’s decision will depend on how aggressively they want to compete this season and their willingness to sacrifice future assets. Ultimately, the Jets’ ability to adapt to this adversity will determine if they can salvage their playoff aspirations.
