Cody Rhodes, often referred to as “The American Nightmare,” has been one of WWE’s biggest stars since his dramatic return to the company in 2022. His journey to the top, culminating in his long-awaited championship victory, marked a significant moment not only for his career but also for WWE storytelling. However, as with all great title reigns in wrestling, the inevitable question looms: Who will WWE choose to dethrone him?
Recent reports have sparked speculation about potential challengers to Cody’s title reign. WWE is known for its intricate storytelling and long-term booking, so the decision to end Cody’s reign will likely be a calculated move to elevate another superstar or push a compelling narrative. Let’s explore the names being rumored to end Cody’s reign and the reasoning behind each candidate.
1. Roman Reigns
It’s no surprise that Roman Reigns, the leader of The Bloodline and one of WWE’s most dominant champions in history, tops the list of potential challengers. After holding the Universal Championship for over three years, Roman has become synonymous with dominance in WWE.
A rematch between Cody Rhodes and Roman Reigns is an easy sell, especially given their history. Cody’s victory over Roman could be seen as unfinished business that Reigns will want to settle. Moreover, the storytelling possibilities with The Bloodline, which has fractured in recent months, could add layers of drama to their feud.
If Roman were to dethrone Cody, it would solidify him further as the face of the company. However, some argue that Roman doesn’t need another title reign, and giving him the championship again might overshadow other rising stars.
2. Seth Rollins
Seth Rollins is another logical choice to end Cody Rhodes’ reign. The rivalry between Cody and Seth has been one of the most captivating feuds in recent WWE history. Their trilogy of matches in 2022, including the unforgettable Hell in a Cell match where Cody wrestled with a torn pectoral muscle, cemented their status as two of WWE’s top performers.
Rollins currently holds the World Heavyweight Championship, but a title unification storyline could create a high-stakes narrative. Seth is a proven main-event player, and his charisma, in-ring skills, and ability to generate heat make him a credible threat to Cody’s reign. A victory over Cody would also add another accolade to Seth’s already impressive resume.
3. Gunther
Gunther, the current Intercontinental Champion, has been on a meteoric rise in WWE. Known as “The Ring General,” Gunther has redefined what it means to be a dominant mid-card champion, holding the Intercontinental Championship for a record-breaking reign.
Many fans and analysts believe Gunther is being groomed for a main-event push, and ending Cody’s title reign could be the perfect way to establish him as a top-tier star. Gunther’s hard-hitting style and commanding presence make him a unique and credible challenger. A clash between Cody’s underdog spirit and Gunther’s raw power would be a compelling story.
4. Solo Sikoa
Solo Sikoa, the enforcer of The Bloodline, has been quietly building his resume as one of WWE’s most promising young stars. While Roman Reigns is the face of the family, Solo has shown flashes of being a dominant force in his own right.
WWE could use Cody’s title reign as an opportunity to elevate Solo to main-event status. A storyline where Solo steps out of Roman’s shadow to claim the championship would not only shake up The Bloodline dynamic but also give WWE a fresh new star in the main-event scene.
WWE’s Long-Term Strategy
WWE’s decision on who will end Cody Rhodes’ title reign will likely hinge on long-term booking plans. Cody’s journey to the championship was rooted in emotional storytelling, centered around fulfilling his late father Dusty Rhodes’ dream. Ending his reign prematurely could risk undermining that narrative.
However, WWE also needs to build new stars and maintain fresh storylines. Whether it’s a proven main-eventer like Roman or Seth, or an emerging force like Gunther or Solo, the decision will shape the company’s future for years to come.
Conclusion
Cody Rhodes’ title reign has brought excitement and emotion to WWE programming, but no reign lasts forever. As WWE considers who will eventually dethrone “The American Nightmare,” they must balance honoring Cody’s story with elevating the next challenger. Whether it’s a returning Roman Reigns, a resurgent Seth Rollins, or a rising star like Gunther or Solo Sikoa, the end of Cody’s reign promises to be one of WWE’s most impactful moments. Fans will be watching closely to see how the next chapter unfolds.
